All brands, all models · Sales · Rentals · Service & AMC · Spare parts · Used & refurbished+91 99590 60718WhatsAppEmailSecunderabad / Hyderabad
REDDY COMPRESSORS

Energy optimisation

Base, trim and VSD energy optimisation

8 min read14 sections

Jump to the calculator ↓

What do base and trim actually mean?

Base and trim describe a compressor’s role in the system, not its motor technology.

  • Base compressor: carries a persistent part of plant demand and spends most of its running time at or near an efficient full-load condition, rather than cycling between load and unload.
  • Trim compressor: follows the remaining, moving part of demand after the base machines have supplied their share.

Put simply: trim requirement = plant demand − total base capacity running. A fixed-speed screw is often an excellent base machine. A VSD screw is often an excellent trim machine. Neither is automatically right; the plant’s demand curve decides.

Energy optimisation starts with the demand-duration curve

Before deciding which machine does what, measure how demand behaves. Log flow, or power and pressure from which flow can be estimated, for at least a typical week. Then sort the data into demand bins, such as 0–20%, 20–40% and so on of station capacity, and count the hours spent in each. This demand-duration profile shows:

  • The persistent demand that is present for most hours: this sets the base load.
  • The range over which demand moves: this sets the trim range the VSD must cover.
  • Low-demand periods, such as nights and weekends, where a different sequence may be needed.

Our demand assessment and load profiling page explains logging methods.

Why fixed speed makes a good base and VSD a good trim

A fixed-speed oil-injected screw compressor running fully loaded is efficient and carries no inverter losses. Its weakness is part load: when it unloads, it still draws a significant share of its full-load power until it stops. So it should be loaded fully or not run.

A VSD machine reduces speed with demand and so avoids most unloaded running, but it is not free of part-load penalty. Efficiency falls at low speed, and below its minimum speed it must stop or unload. Use the manufacturer’s verified specific-power curve, kW per m³/min across the speed range, rather than a single best-point figure.

Simple base/trim example

Suppose a plant’s demand swings between 14 and 24 m³/min over a typical day. It has two fixed-speed compressors of 10 m³/min each and one VSD compressor with a usable range of 3–14 m³/min.

Plant demandBase machines loadedVSD outputComment
14 m³/minOne (10)4VSD near the low end of its range
18 m³/minOne (10)8VSD mid-range, efficient
22 m³/minOne (10)12VSD near maximum
24 m³/minTwo (20)4Second base machine starts; VSD drops back

Because the VSD range (11 m³/min usable) is larger than one fixed-speed step (10 m³/min), every demand level can be met with the fixed machines fully loaded. If the VSD covered only 6 m³/min, there would be a control gap.

Control-gap engineering

A control gap exists when the VSD’s usable range is smaller than the step size of the fixed-speed machines. When demand sits in that gap, the VSD reaches its limit and a fixed-speed machine starts, runs partly unloaded, stops and starts again. The station ends up with exactly the unloaded running VSD was meant to remove.

  • Size the trim VSD so its usable range, between minimum stable output and maximum output, is at least the largest fixed-speed step, with some margin.
  • Where machines are of different sizes, check every combination, not just the largest step.
  • Remember that one VSD among several machines does not optimise the station on its own; sequencing does.

Sequencing and pressure hierarchy

Individual compressors with their own pressure switches often fight each other: several machines unload together, or the VSD and a fixed-speed machine both try to trim. A master controller that reads one header pressure and decides which machines load, unload, start and stop solves this.

  • Set one target pressure band for the station, based on the minimum the plant needs plus realistic losses.
  • Give the VSD the trim role within that band, and give the fixed-speed machines load and unload points that let the VSD act first.
  • Lower the target pressure once control is stable. As a typical rule, each extra bar costs about 7% more compressor power.
  • Rotate base machines for even running hours, but keep the energy-optimal combination in service.

See controls, sequencing and multi-compressor optimisation for controller types.

Storage is part of the control system

Air receivers give the controller time to respond and reduce short cycling. Usable storage depends on the pressure swing allowed, not just the vessel volume: a receiver allowed only a very small pressure swing stores little useful air. Put receivers where they help control, usually after the dryer near the station header, and add local storage near large intermittent users so their peaks do not start extra compressors. Our storage for energy optimisation page covers sizing.

Measure load and unload power, do not assume it

Unloaded power varies between machines, controls and condition. A worked example shows why it matters: a fixed-speed compressor drawing 75 kW loaded and, say, 25 kW unloaded, that spends 3,000 hours a year unloaded, uses 75,000 kWh of electricity producing no air. Only logging shows the real figures for your machines. Our unload and idle loss reduction page explains what to measure.

Common base/trim mistakes

MistakeResultBetter approach
VSD forced to run as base load at full speedInverter losses with no part-load benefitLet fixed-speed machines carry base; VSD trims
Fixed-speed machine left to trimLong unloaded runningGive trim to the VSD or adjust sequence
VSD too small for the step sizeControl gap and cyclingResize VSD or change fixed-machine combination
Standby machine left runningPermanent unloaded loadStart standby only on demand or fault
Lead/lag rotation by timer onlyEven hours but poor energyRotate within energy-optimal combinations
Raising pressure to cure a dropHigher energy and leaksFind the restriction or add local storage

Reliability and start limits

The lowest kW should never come at the cost of air supply. Keep enough standby capacity for the loss of the largest machine where production is critical. Respect each motor’s permitted starts per hour, which the sequence must not exceed. Low-demand periods may need a different regime, such as the VSD alone on nights, with a fixed-speed machine allowed to start only on falling pressure.

Reducing demand first, by fixing leaks and stopping artificial demand, often changes the optimal sequence completely. Re-check the sequence after any significant leak campaign.

A practical optimisation sequence

  1. Log power, pressure and, where possible, flow for every compressor for at least one typical week.
  2. Fix major leaks and remove artificial demand, then log again if the change is large.
  3. Build the demand-duration profile and identify base load, trim range and low-demand periods.
  4. Check the VSD’s usable range against every fixed-speed step to find control gaps.
  5. Set up one master controller with a single target pressure band.
  6. Reduce the target pressure in small steps while watching the most sensitive users.
  7. Review storage and add local receivers where peaks start extra machines.
  8. Re-log to verify the result in kWh and specific power.

How Reddy Compressors helps

We are an independent multi-brand specialist at Tarnaka, Secunderabad, serving industry since 2002, and not an authorised dealer of any brand. We have tie-ups with all major and reputed brands. That lets us optimise stations that mix ELGi, Atlas Copco, Ingersoll Rand, KAESER, Chicago Pneumatic and other makes.

  • Power, pressure and flow logging to build your demand-duration profile.
  • Assessment of base/trim roles, control gaps, set points and storage.
  • Supply of new or used/refurbished VSD and fixed-speed screw compressors where a change of machine is needed.
  • Service and AMC for the whole station, with more than 20 service engineers and technicians across Telangana and Andhra Pradesh.
  • Rental compressors from our own fleet to cover changeovers, with supply across India.

What to send us

  • List of compressors with make, model, rated flow, pressure and power, and whether each is fixed speed or VSD.
  • Current controls: individual pressure switches or a master controller.
  • Pressure set points and the minimum pressure the plant needs.
  • Receiver sizes and locations, and dryer type.
  • Shift pattern and any existing power or pressure logs.

Frequently asked questions

Should my VSD compressor be the base load or trim machine?

In most multi-compressor stations the VSD should be the trim machine, following the changing part of demand, while fixed-speed compressors carry the steady base load fully loaded. Running a VSD at full speed all day gives inverter losses without part-load benefit. The exception is a plant whose base demand itself varies widely, where the demand profile may justify another arrangement.

What is a control gap in compressor sequencing?

A control gap occurs when the VSD’s usable output range is smaller than the step size of the fixed-speed machines. When demand falls inside that gap, a fixed-speed machine has to start, run partly unloaded and stop repeatedly. The cure is a VSD with a large enough usable range, or a different combination of fixed-speed machine sizes.

Do I need a master controller for multiple compressors?

Where two or more compressors serve one header, a master controller is usually worthwhile. It reads one pressure signal and decides which machines load, unload, start and stop, so they stop fighting each other. It also allows a narrower pressure band and a lower set point, both of which save energy. Settings must suit your machines and demand pattern.

How much power does an unloaded screw compressor use?

It varies with the machine, its controls and its condition, so it should be measured rather than assumed. Unloaded power is a significant share of full-load power on many fixed-speed screw compressors, which is why long unloaded running wastes energy. Logging power alongside load and unload signals shows exactly how many kWh a year are spent producing no air.

Can adding a VSD to a station reduce energy bills?

It can, if the station currently has long unloaded running or wide pressure bands, and if the VSD is sized to cover the fixed-speed step and is properly sequenced. A VSD added without sequencing, or one too small for the gap, may save little. Log the station first, then model the new arrangement against your demand profile.

How should standby compressors be controlled?

A standby compressor should be ready to start automatically on falling pressure or a fault in a running machine, but should not run unloaded all the time just in case. Check that the master controller can start it quickly, that the receiver gives enough time for it to come on load, and that it is exercised regularly.

Field guide

Base, trim and VSD: The energy view

The control arrangement of a multi-compressor station often decides more of the energy bill than the efficiency of any single machine. The goal is simple: as few machines as possible running unloaded, and only one machine part-loaded.

What to look at

MeasurementGood signWarning sign
Unloaded hours on fixed machinesLow share of total hoursHigh share: machine is trimming
VSD speed trendMostly mid-rangeAlways at maximum, or cycling at minimum
Number of machines running at nightMatches night demandSame as day shift
Pressure bandNarrow and stableWide swings or staggered settings

Improvements often come from settings and sequencing rather than new equipment. Where a new machine is justified, a correctly sized VSD as the single trim machine is usually the first candidate. See base and trim control.

What to send for a quotation

  • Compressor make, model and rated power of each machine.
  • Electricity tariff and annual running hours.
  • Typical pressure at the compressor and at the furthest user.
  • Any measurements you already have (power, flow, loaded hours).

Send it through the audit and measurement enquiry or the engineering consultation enquiry, or call +91 99590 60718 or +91 92468 88812.

Calculators and worked examples

These tools give indicative figures for screening, comparison and for preparing an enquiry. They run in your browser and send nothing. No prices or tariffs are assumed: enter your own to see costs. Efficiencies and other figures shown are example values: replace them with your own. Results are not a performance guarantee or a design certificate; final selection is confirmed by a service engineer against the machine data sheet and the site.

Part-load fleet dispatch (single demand point)

For one plant demand, list every feasible combination of up to three compressors, put the others on base load and one on trim, and rank the states by total package kW.

The worked example below shows the method with fixed numbers. Turn on JavaScript to change the inputs.

Worked example

Inputs
  • Plant demand to be met (m³/min free air): 10
  • Machine A: type: Fixed speed, load/unload
  • Machine A: full-load flow, FAD at duty pressure (m³/min): 6
  • Machine A: package power at full flow (kW): 40
  • Machine A, fixed speed only: unloaded power (kW): 12
  • Machine A, VSD only: minimum stable flow (m³/min): 0
  • Machine A, VSD only: power at minimum flow (kW): 0
  • Machine B: type: Fixed speed, load/unload
  • Machine B: full-load flow, FAD at duty pressure (m³/min): 6
  • Machine B: package power at full flow (kW): 40
  • Machine B, fixed speed only: unloaded power (kW): 12
  • Machine B, VSD only: minimum stable flow (m³/min): 0
  • Machine B, VSD only: power at minimum flow (kW): 0
  • Machine C: type: Variable speed (VSD)
  • Machine C: full-load flow, FAD at duty pressure (m³/min): 7.5
  • Machine C: package power at full flow (kW): 48
  • Machine C, fixed speed only: unloaded power (kW): 0
  • Machine C, VSD only: minimum stable flow (m³/min): 2
  • Machine C, VSD only: power at minimum flow (kW): 15
  • Running hours per year at this demand: 6,000
Result
  • 1. A + C: 67 kW, 6.7 kW per m³/min; trim C at 4 m³/min (VSD), others fully loaded
  • 2. B + C: 67 kW, 6.7 kW per m³/min; trim C at 4 m³/min (VSD), others fully loaded
  • 3. A + B: 70.7 kW, 7.07 kW per m³/min; trim A at 4 m³/min (67% loaded), others fully loaded
  • Lowest-power state: A + C trim C at 4 m³/min (VSD), others fully loaded
  • Specific power of that state: 6.7 kW per m³/min
  • Annual energy in that state: 4,02,000 kWh per year
  • N+1 check (lose machine C): Passes other available machines can give 12 m³/min against 10 m³/min demand
  • Lowest-power state that also passes N+1: Same as above
  • Saving against the next higher-power state (A + B): 3.67 kW = 22,000 kWh per year

Method. Single-demand-point mode. Every on/off combination of the available machines is tried, with each online machine in turn as the trim machine. Base machines run fully loaded at their FAD and full-flow kW; the trim machine takes the remainder. A state is feasible only if the remainder is above 0, no more than the trim machine’s full flow, and (for a VSD trim) not below its minimum stable flow. Fixed-speed trim on load/unload: kW = x × loaded kW + (1 − x) × unloaded kW, with x = trim flow ÷ full flow (ignores extra blowdown losses with small storage). VSD trim: kW interpolated linearly between the minimum-flow and full-flow points. Specific power = total kW ÷ demand. N+1 check: with the largest online machine lost, all other available machines together must still cover the demand (assumes standby machines can start in time). Annual kWh = kW × hours at this demand. The lowest-power state that also passes N+1 is shown when the cheapest state does not. Use package kW and FAD at the same duty pressure for every machine. Not included: the demand sweep, annual load profile and scenario modes described on the page; run the tool once per demand band and weight each result by the hours in that band (annual kWh = Σ kW × hours).

What to take from it. Run the base machines fully loaded and give the trim role to the machine with the flattest part-load curve; two fixed-speed machines both partly unloaded is usually the most expensive way to meet the same flow.

Technical content reviewed by D. Srinivas Reddy, Managing Partner and service engineer, Reddy Compressors. Last updated 17 October 2026. How our engineering content is reviewed.

Load/unload cycle energy

Turn measured load and unload times (or the logged percentage of time in each state) and measured package kW into average power, annual energy, the energy spent running unloaded, and specific power based on the air actually delivered. An optional second set of times compares a change.

The worked example below shows the method with fixed numbers. Turn on JavaScript to change the inputs.

Worked example

Inputs
  • Times entered as: Measured cycle times (seconds)
  • Loaded package power (kW): 82
  • Unloaded package power (kW): 28
  • Loaded time (s per cycle, or per cent): 40
  • Unloaded time (s per cycle, or per cent): 60
  • Stopped time, motor off, 0 if none (s per cycle, or per cent): 0
  • Power while stopped, controls only (kW): 0
  • Running hours per year with this cycle pattern: 6,000
  • Free air delivered when loaded, FAD (m³/min): 12.5
  • After change, optional: loaded time, all three 0 = not used (s or per cent): 0
  • After change, optional: unloaded time (s or per cent): 0
  • After change, optional: stopped time (s or per cent): 0
Result
  • Cycle time: 100 s (36 cycles per hour)
  • Loaded fraction: 40%
  • Unloaded fraction: 60%
  • Unloaded power as a share of loaded power: 34.1%
  • Average package power: 49.6 kW
  • Annual energy: 2,97,600 kWh per year
  • Unload energy (buys no air): 1,00,800 kWh per year = 33.9% of the annual energy
  • Loaded specific power: 6.56 kW per m³/min
  • Average air delivered: 5 m³/min
  • Effective specific power over the cycle: 9.92 kW per m³/min
  • Energy cost per year: Enter your electricity tariff (cost per kWh) above

Method. Two input modes. Cycle timing: enter measured seconds per cycle. Fraction: enter the share of time loaded, unloaded and stopped (for example 40, 60, 0, from controller loaded/running hours); no cycle time is reported in this mode. Average kW = (P_load × t_load + P_unload × t_unload + P_stopped × t_stopped) ÷ (t_load + t_unload + t_stopped); the states must not overlap. Annual kWh = average kW × the hours this pattern runs. Unload energy = P_unload × unloaded fraction × hours. Average air delivered = loaded fraction × loaded FAD; effective specific power = average kW ÷ average air delivered. Unloaded power is never assumed to be zero: enter measured package kW (unloaded read after blowdown has settled). Scenario comparison: enter the predicted times after a change (bigger receiver, wider band, auto-stop) in the “after change” fields; the same powers, FAD and hours are used and the kWh difference is shown. An auto-stop timer is modelled by moving unload time into the stopped state (check the motor’s permitted starts per hour). For different day and night patterns, run the tool once per pattern and add the results. The rapid-cycling warning below 30 s per cycle is our recommended check level. Money is shown only when you enter your own tariff.

What to take from it. A large unload-energy share, or an effective specific power well above the loaded figure, means a fixed-speed machine is running lightly loaded: look at storage, pressure band, sequencing, auto-stop or a smaller/VSD trim machine.

Talk to Reddy Compressors

Tell us the job. We will send the right answer.

Buying, hiring, servicing or looking for a part: share what the air must run, the pressure and the site. A nameplate photo is often enough to start.

+91 99590 60718+91 92468 88812